swizzle:Still coming up with almost nothing. Its the Calvary Reformed or Calvary Presbyterian Reformed church in Hagaman, NY in Montgomery county. I'm still trying. This is the one that was built in 1835. I gotta bookmark this one as an extra resource. Thanx for the extra resource help. Maybe I'll get one of these 2 churches posted soon. Swizzle
The historical marker should be enough to proove the age
The church web sote at http://www.hagamanreformedchurch.org/about/ is also proof of age
Try this:
http://www.fortklock.com/rcahagaman.htm
if the picture matches maybe a name change. It seems odd that there would be 2 reformed presbyterian churches in a small town.