cldisme:
I voted no because there was already a Independent Diners category that serves exactly that purpose you so desire.
I think you are wrong in this conclusion, it was a reason to decline the category when it was only the one show but now it is much broader. Actually the title may be wrong for the category. I think if you check the places that Rachel Ray has visited or those in Feasing on Waves you will find most are not diners. And once you consider that any national syndicate food show can be included I am sure I can find a show featuring Charlie Trotters (
Mobil Five Star, AAA Five Diamond).... if you consider that a diner it would be a pretty fancy diner

I would not consider Katz or Carnegie Deli's in NYC as diners either.