I am liking the look of this category. Thanks for continuing to work on it. You have done a good job.
Some thoughts.
"please estimate the
significance of this place in the past and when it was built and/or
abandoned."
I
do not like this particular line. On the Internet if someone posts an
estimate of significance in one place it becomes fact at another. If a
waymarker doesn't know about an item I don't think he should guess.
---
>>> Sorry, but the category is historical. The history is important... This part is here for people who didnt find history. I extend the definition with this sentece: A summary of the history of the place is required. If you don't find any information about the locations history, please estimate the significance of this place in the past and when it was built and/or abandoned. If you estimated the significance of the place, please write this fact in the listing too.
"Waymark must be on an unpopulated place in nature."
On should be at her. At an unpopulated place.
---
>>> I agree, it was modified...
"Place should not have architectural or archaeological value..." I think any remains or ruin of any sort has the potential of archaeological value. So maybe it might be further clarified as;
Place should not have architectural or known/significant archaeological value...
---
>>> I agree, it was modified...
"A summary of the history of the place is required."
I don't know if I would require this. Some locations would make a
wonderful waymark but the poster might not know the history. A visitor
later might have information that could be shared that would never be
made known if the waymark were not created.
---
>>> In my first answer...
"At least one photo is required." Require two. One closeup and one area view. This will give a better sense of the location.
---
>>> I agree, but there are places, where 1 photo is enought, so I left it... It is on desicion of owner...
I
like the examples section. I think that in some minor cases the
readability can be improved. This is not a criticism at all. I am
impressed by how well it has transformed.
Here are my suggestions.
-
Within is a scenic forest we can find evidence of an orchard and some
ruins of a homestead here (but nothing with architectural or
known archaeological value). There is a tragic but interesting story about
last owners of this homestead.
- There is an old water well on the edge of the forest. This well
produced water for a nearby hunting hut (there no remains of this
hunting hut here but there are remains of a water canal that was
connecting the hunting hut and the well). Native people say that if
somebody drank the water from this well and lied the same day, he died
exactly one year after that drinking.
- An old swimming pool found in ruin. Originally, this pool was (remove second originally) at the residence of a factory owner. After World War 2,
communism took hold and the property was confiscated by the government. The
pool and property, no longer being maintained fell into ruin. Today,
the pool is all that remains.
- An old row of trees remains in a somewhat odd location. The history
of the area indicate that this is a fence line of trees that was on an
abandoned road leading to an old silver mine. The remains of the road
are over grown with grass and brush, but these beautiful old trees
remain here to attest to the former location of a road. (NOTE: The
abandoned mine is not waymarkable in this category. Please use the
"Mines" category instead. The row of trees is the subject.)
---
>>>Thank you for your points. I corrected it..
I am
impressed by how well it has transformed. - it is due to my friend Krovicko and our new member GParkes...
Thank you very much for your opinion...
Roman