FiVermont:Any possibility of info on rejected categories?
Not having been involved with Waymarking all that long, I'm somewhat curious as to what cats haven't made it through peer review.
It wouldn't have to be interactive at all, just a listing with the description and vote count. Vote comments would also be interesting.
Matt
I like Matt's idea... even if it's just a list of categories that have passed through Peer Review and crashed.
For denied and approved categories, I'm in favor of the Peer Review comments having some sort of permanence. When a category is denied, the peer review comments are no longer accessible when a new category is established by that group. I think it would be nice if Peer Review comments (for however many categories or attempts) were kept accessible via a link from the group's Past Activity section.
On a user level, I think it'd be interesting to have a voting history. That doesn't have to be public or anything... but I'd like to review what I voted on what when. This may be an exhaustive list for some waymarkers, but it could still be useful.
(my two cents)
- Elle