Recruiting and Category Proposals

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

macleod1 — Thu, 04 Jun 2009 10:45:48 GMT

What's wrong with seeing a few extra smiles in your day? It's going to depend on the wording with this category. You don't want to be flooded with ordinary advertising signs but pics that are a bit different, like the side of a barn, silo, water tower or even cut into the grass on a hillside. Not all categories have to be serious. I say go for it.

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

onfire4jesus — Mon, 01 Jun 2009 16:04:02 GMT

Please, please, please , please no...

Just kidding. Doesn't thrill me (translation I'm not interested in being an officer), but it seems a reasonable category and I would probably post more than the "one to get the icon".

Sounds like you already have it pretty well defined - my first concern was the transient nature of signs, but you seem to have that covered. Off the top of my head it seems like it has a good prevalence, Maybe a little on the high side, but nothing like benchmarks or national register of historical places - at least not in my area.

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

silverquill — Sat, 30 May 2009 11:59:47 GMT

Seems pretty trivial to me, but if it's fun for someone, then I guess there's a place for it. I do think it would be a tricky one to write so that it works, though.

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

dinoprophet — Sat, 30 May 2009 01:39:16 GMT

I saw a smiley face on a silo this weekend and wondered if there was a category. Would have to be well-defined (and I'd say permanent).

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

the blue quasar — Thu, 28 May 2009 03:01:25 GMT

With a clear definition of scope, I can see this being fun. If it's too vague, then all I can say is that you will be disappointed with many submissions.

BQ

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

Redneck Parrotheads — Thu, 28 May 2009 02:09:22 GMT

I can see this going somewhere and it compliments Geocaching in an off-hand way (with a pleasant exclusion of Wally Worlds).

Re: Smiley Faces Signs

scooter bill — Thu, 28 May 2009 01:21:44 GMT

I'll support any category that takes me to something interesting, historic, scenic, unusual, or useful, but I don't see this one fitting into my tastes.

Smiley Faces Signs

mtekk77 — Wed, 27 May 2009 22:02:14 GMT

Would a category where Smiley face(s) on advertising signs be a good possibility? The sign would need to be permanent, not a banner, billboard, streamer or painted on a window. Preferred would be outdoor signs mounted on a pole, etc..

Example say, would be if there was a buisness named "Smiley's Grocery" and there was a smiley face on the sign.

Example for NOT allowed would be like Walmart "Rollback" banners that most stores have somewhere in or around store. Or if "Smiley's Grocery" has a billboard out by the Interstate etc..

Also any type of smiley, etc.. would be allowed as long as it is publicly displayed and accessible for logging a visit.

I did search for category, and my search did not turn up anything.

If there is one, I apologize

Thanks for any input either good or bad