Groundspeak Portal

The Language of Location
Welcome to Groundspeak Portal Sign in | Join | Help
in
Home Blogs Forums

Peer Review

Last post 04-10-2009, 4:33 PM by Redneck Parrotheads. 7 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  04-09-2009, 8:24 AM 22201

    Peer Review

    If I chose to abstain on new category peer review, does this count as a negative or neutral vote?
  •  04-09-2009, 1:10 PM 22205 in reply to 22201

    Re: Peer Review

    Abstain is neutral.
  •  04-09-2009, 5:32 PM 22209 in reply to 22201

    Re: Peer Review

    It is like you have not voted at all as far as count.  You can put comments in on your abstain which are important.
  •  04-10-2009, 3:52 AM 22212 in reply to 22209

    Re: Peer Review

    Thank you, that is what I thougth, but wanted to sure. I with choice to abstain when I see a group that I have no interest in, but think that others may. I will vote No on those that I think shoiuld not granted.

     

  •  04-10-2009, 8:28 AM 22218 in reply to 22212

    Re: Peer Review

    My first attempt at a new category was not approved (yes I know that happens to everybody). However, when I looked at the results this what I found was the results of the voting to be.

    Yes - 29

    No - 22

    Abstain - 7

    So why if the majority said yes to the category did it not get approved?

  •  04-10-2009, 8:30 AM 22219 in reply to 22218

    Re: Peer Review

    I think it is a 2/3rds majority.
  •  04-10-2009, 1:40 PM 22220 in reply to 22219

    Re: Peer Review

    TheBeanTeam:
    I think it is a 2/3rds majority.

     

    It is 66%, so if those 7 who abstained had voted yes, you would've passed. I would look at the nay comments and fix objections  and resubmit.

  •  04-10-2009, 4:33 PM 22221 in reply to 22212

    Re: Peer Review

    woolsox:

    Thank you, that is what I thougth, but wanted to sure. I with choice to abstain when I see a group that I have no interest in, but think that others may. I will vote No on those that I think shoiuld not granted.

    If you have no interest in a category, you have the choice of not posting or visiting waymarks into that category. Your opinion about the category is irrelevant in Peer Review, even for an Abstain vote.

    In Peer Review, your vote should be based on the guidelines, which are outlined on the Peer Review page.

    The time to vote Abstain is when you have no desire to vote "no" but have a constructive improvement comment that prevents you from voting "yes", or when you are truly undecided but wish to let the category officers know so they can write a better description after Peer Review. Voting to abstain because of your personal opinion about the subject matter, because maybe one of the officers didn't say something you liked in the forum, or because you just want to click a form button is a waste of vote and time for the category officers.

    The more you practice leaving your personal opinion about a category's subject during Peer Review, the better. It'll also keep you from voting to approve a category you really like that needs serious work before it appears in the directory.

View as RSS news feed in XML
Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems